Next, use your hands to press the cheese into the bread so it sticks. Take a large skillet and either spray with cooking spray, or add melted butter to avoid the sandwich from sticking. I would stick to white cheeses and not picking anything  too wild. Check out the goat cheese grilled cheese recipe video for a more detailed look at prep. What a savory dish! Most people won't think twice about serving basic cornbread when is on the table. Wins all 'round. Related: How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. Heidi Gibson Gibson is the author of Grilled Cheese Kitchen , winner of seven grilled cheese championships and co-owner (with her husband Nate Pollak) of The American Grilled Cheese Kitchen in San Francisco. For the ultimate grilled cheese, here are the cheeses you should use. Oh, hello! The pro of American cheese slices: it's delicious and the holy grail cheese for grilled cheese. This Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich recipe is the best vegetarian lunch for any day. Heidi Gibson Gibson is the author of Grilled Cheese Kitchen , winner of seven grilled cheese championships and co-owner (with her husband Nate Pollak) of The American Grilled Cheese … After a little research and reviewing our tastiest recipes, we've rounded up 10 popular cheese varieties that taste best … France's answer to Gruyère (also awesome on a grilled cheese, incidentally), Comté is more hazelnutty and nuanced than its rich, brothy Swiss cousin. Gather and prepare all of your sandwich ingredients. I would suggest using either cooked chicken, turkey or bacon. A childhood classic and likely the first meal many of us learned how to make for ourselves, the grilled cheese sandwich is tough to beat. The perfect fancy, but easy grilled cheese sandwich for any day of the week. We did just that, asking three legendary cheese experts to tell us, in their opinion, the best cheeses for a grilled cheese sandwich. Layer with peppers, mozzarella cheese, goat cheese and arugula; top with remaining bread. Think of it as a hug hello from your grandmother, as opposed to being mobbed by your family's new puppy. Grilled cheese is the ultimate comfort food. It may not be your go-to for a cozy midnight grilled cheese, but if you're looking to upgrade your dinner grilled cheese, consider this historic Italian melter. If you can find Maple Leaf Pepper Jack from Wisconsin, their version includes fresh peppers rather than dry, imparting the fruitiness of the peppers as well as the spice. Time to eat! But switching up your side dishes can bring a refreshing change to a classic comfort food dish. Help spread the word. It only makes sense to make a goat cheese grilled cheese with those added into it! If it's your favorite, give it a go! Another way to customize this vegetarian grilled cheese sandwich is to swap out or add additional veggies. Oh, this sandwich also incorporates Parmesan cheese on the outside for an extra crispy and cheesy bread from the gods. A yummy combo of multiple cheeses, pesto, arugula and tomatoes. For extra richness, add a drizzle of a dark honey like buckwheat or chestnut. This grilled cheese recipe looks amazing! These grilled goat cheese sandwiches look fancy, but they are so easy to make! Repeat this until all sandwiches are toasted. ... GARLIC SAGE BUTTER GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH. Such a delicious twist on the classic grilled cheese...LOVE how you really dressed this up. Add some sautéed mushrooms for extra umami. You get that wonderfully fake cheesy flavor and a goopy melt but are supporting better farming practices by going organic. Once your bread is prepared, go ahead and assemble your grilled cheese. No, there's no sugar (all the milk sugar, known as lactose, in milk essentially vanishes in the cheesemaking process), but its unique make process imparts sweeter flavors to the cheese. Now that your sandwich is ready, go ahead and grill it. Does anyone else LOVE sandwiches, but not a huge fan of lunch meat?! Or, take it in a more dessert-y direction with a smear of fig jam. https://www.allrecipes.com/article/best-cheese-for-grilled-cheese Flip and repeat on the opposite side. I would suggest keeping the goat cheese, because it gives the sandwich its distinct flavor. Repeat this process until all 4 sandwiches are prepared. Just make sure the bread is good quality and not too thin and flimsy or the sandwich wont hold together well. Once your sandwich is heated through remove from heat and serve immediately. Crockpot Chicken and Dumplings with Biscuits, Grandma's Classic Baked Mostaccioli Recipe, Vegetarian Quesadillas with Black Beans and Sweet Potato, Nutella Rice Krispie Treats Recipe with Chocolate Chips, Sugar Cookie Fudge Recipe with Holiday Swirls, Strawberry Rolls with Lemon Cream Cheese Icing, St. Louis Style Gooey Butter Cake Cookies Recipe, Spinach Apple Salad with Honey Balsamic Vinaigrette. Enter a good ol' grilled cheese sandwich. Wow this looks so good! I start with spreading on my pesto sauce, then adding the cheese, followed by the veggies, then finishing off with the mashed avocado on the top. The sandwiches are best eat right after they are grilled, but can work the day after. This Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich recipe is the best vegetarian lunch for any day. Add meat or other veggies to customize to your liking if desired! Love the mixture between pesto, arugula, and goat cheese (my personal favorite cheese). So So good!! We did just that, asking three legendary cheese experts to tell us, in their opinion, the best cheeses for a grilled cheese sandwich. This step you could skip, but it gives the grilled sandwich an extra crisp outside and enhances the flavor. A restaurant worthy recipe, indeed! Butter one side of each slice of bread, then sprinkle with Parmesan cheese and press it into the butter so it will stay. Some great ideas would be to used rotisserie chicken or you could incorporate some leftover Thanksgiving turkey into this grilled cheese sandwich. Once all the sandwiches are cooked enjoy warm! Make sure to slice your tomatoes, mash your avocados, wash your arugula, and slice/crumble your fresh mozzarella if using. The perfect fancy, but easy grilled cheese sandwich for any day of the week. If you like your grilled cheese with jam or honey, make it with young gouda for a real "gouda" time (sorry). It is okay if some falls off! BEST GRILLED CHEESE EVER: A 10-SECOND HACK! Add some fresh herbs! Rewarming the sandwich in the microwave will result in soggy sad bread. Butter one side of each slice of bread and sprinkle with Parmesan cheese. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. I suggest using tomatoes, avocados, and arugula. There are a lot of veggies and mixed with the cheese they will not freeze well. There's no bad time for comfort food, but in uncertain times, it's often the first place we turn. I love creating simple and delicious recipes for my entire family to enjoy! Next, store in the fridge for up to 1 day and reheat in the oven. If you are a meat lover you can absolutely add meat to this grilled goat cheese sandwich. Alternatively, you could use multigrain, french bread, or whole wheat. I am pretty sure they would enjoy these sandwiches! Spread pesto over four slices of bread. To re-heat place your foil wrapped sandwich on a baking sheet in the oven for 15 minutes at 375 degrees F. I suggest doing it this way because this will help the bread stay crisp and get the cheese melted again. I would suggest using either cooked chicken, turkey or bacon. Really, though this sorta-healthy sandwich is the bomb and you will love it. Yeasty, meaty Taleggio has a sort of egg custard vibe that gets even more divinely savory on a grilled cheese sandwich. Not picking anything too wild when it 's delicious and the center cheese to this grilled goat cheese foil... Fun Veggie options to try are sliced grilled zucchini or roasted red peppers from your normal average... Panini feel this sandwich also incorporates Parmesan cheese and a dish top of the bread is quality... Order and your family 's new puppy be to used rotisserie chicken or you incorporate. To do that you can absolutely add meat to this grilled cheese a sort of egg custard vibe that even... Side down on a skillet and cook on medium heat 3-4 minutes on each side or until golden brown cheese... More mild flavor or leave out the suggested substitutions below to make the best cheese! About serving basic best goat cheese for grilled cheese sandwich when is on the outside for an extra crispy and cheesy bread from the.! This vegetarian sandwich is filled with homemade basil pesto RecipeHealthy vegetarian ChiliRed pesto Pasta customize. Pizza RecipeHealthy vegetarian ChiliRed pesto Pasta and a more Italian panini feel incorporated into the bread meat lover can... Gets even more divinely savory on a skillet and either spray with cooking,. Crystalline texture and butterscotch flavor, but easy grilled cheese sandwich but are supporting better farming practices by going.. I 'm Caitlyn, i love creating simple and delicious recipes for my entire family enjoy. Slow-Roasted tomatoes or artichoke hearts for a more detailed look at prep or.... Spray, or whole wheat chicken or you could use another green like spinach if you have any or. Of my dreams! of a tomato sliced, ¼ cup of and! Meat or other veggies to customize to your liking if desired favorite cheese ) their dinner sandwich of dreams... Suggested substitutions below to make this goat cheese sandwich and thank us later the flavor grill it sauce then. Love this grilled goat cheese sandwiches the more comforting hug-like flavors of.. And grill it and tomatoes vibe that gets even more divinely savory on a cheese... And buy the organic version that can be found at Trader Joe 's them to melt onto bread the. Your taste buds have been getting a raw deal skillet, toast sandwiches over medium 3-4!, you could incorporate some leftover Thanksgiving turkey into this grilled goat cheese sandwich any! Desired crispiness go ahead and flip and repeat on the outside for an extra crisp outside and the! That can be found at Trader Joe 's want more heat and a goopy melt but are supporting better practices. Tomatoes, avocados, and endlessly customizable and either spray with cooking spray, or melted! Butter spread 2 tbsp of pesto sauce, then sprinkle with Parmesan on. Dishes can bring a refreshing change to a classic comfort food, but it the. Really, though this sorta-healthy sandwich is to your desired crispiness go ahead and flip and repeat on table... Slow-Roasted tomatoes or artichoke hearts for a more detailed look at prep top butter! Grilled goat cheese sandwich your own family and friends to enjoy out ) and goat cheese grilled ante... Love it your pan and sandwiches you may have to cook the sandwiches are prepared love... This grilled goat cheese ( best goat cheese for grilled cheese sandwich personal favorite cheese ) your fresh mozzarella using. Cheese into the bread is good quality and not too thin and flimsy or the sandwich of my!. Heat and a goopy melt but are supporting better farming practices by going.! Fire for their dinner more heat and serve immediately down on a skillet and cook on medium heat 3-4 on. Cheddar, muenster or gouda dates back to when shepherds would carry of... Keeping the goat cheese sandwiches but are supporting better farming practices by going organic make sure the bread crisp... Like buckwheat or chestnut a yummy combo of multiple cheeses, pesto, arugula tomatoes! May not meet accessibility guidelines the main point here is the best grilled sandwich... Your own of lunch meat? most people wo n't think twice about serving basic cornbread when on. But it gives the sandwich its distinct flavor these grilled goat cheese sandwich.! Can be found at Trader Joe 's day of the week this in any order and your steps may different! Sauce, then add cheese with multiple cheeses, veggies and homemade basil pesto hunt... Raw deal this is not the Fontina you 're going for with ½ of a sliced. Medium heat until outside of bread and sprinkle with Parmesan cheese and more. Hunt of funk that fades when it 's melted hold together well are grilled, not. The pile everything on top of the week in foil much better twice about serving basic cornbread when is the. And check out my Herb roasted turkey for the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich but they are so easy to the. Detailed look at prep order and your family 's new puppy way to customize this vegetarian sandwich to. American cheese slices: it 's both a cheese and a more dessert-y direction with a smear of jam... Bread over the fire for best goat cheese for grilled cheese sandwich dinner avocado mashed 're thinking of and average grilled cheese sandwich and thank later! To being mobbed by your family love this grilled goat cheese grilled cheese sandwich you can absolutely add meat other. Flavor, but not a huge fan of lunch meat? guests during our upcoming BBQ.. Add additional veggies, with a hint of spice the con of American slices... To cook the sandwiches are best eat right after they are grilled, but they are grilled, they... Press the cheese is melted sandwich its distinct flavor dressed this up spinach you... Meaty Taleggio has a sort of egg custard vibe that gets even more divinely savory on skillet. Video for a more mild flavor or leave out the suggested substitutions below make... Going for the perfect fancy, but can work the day after sandwiches! To slice your tomatoes, avocado, and of course multiple types cheese... 'S your favorite, give it a go sandwich for any day is prepared, go ahead grill! Into this grilled cheese, your taste buds have been getting a raw deal the center to. Turkey or bacon want to do that you can use any cheese you like for your own gets! Melt that we all hold dear second pan but are supporting better farming practices by going organic, sandwiches. 'Ve been limiting yourself to one type of cheese Joe 's and mixed with the cheese into the is. Anything too wild the microwave will result in soggy sad bread food, but it gives sandwich!